"Boycott 'Israel' " bus advertisement is back in the news:

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
By the Associated Press
January 11, 2013, 6:32 AM

DETROIT FREE PRESS
At: http://www.freep.com/article/20130111/NEWS06/130111009/Ann-Arbor-bus-agency-won-t-budge-on-anti-Israel-ad


The agency that runs Ann Arbor's bus system has revised its ad policy but still won't accept an anti-Israel ad.

A federal judge last fall said the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority's policy against certain ads was vague and unconstitutional. The policy has been changed, but the agency still won't post an ad on buses that criticizes Israel.


The ad by Blaine Coleman would have skulls and bones and say, "Boycott 'Israel.' Boycott Apartheid." The bus agency says putting Israel in quotation marks implies that it doesn't exist. The agency says the ad also ridicules a group of people.
Judge Mark Goldsmith wants to read more legal filings from both sides before taking the next step. The lawsuit was filed by the American Civil Liberties Union.

-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
BY ASSOCIATED PRESS
January 11, 2013, 7:10 AM

DETROIT NEWS
At: http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20130111/METRO/301110393/1409/metro/Ann-Arbor-bus-agency-won-t-budge-anti-Israel-ad


Ann Arbor — The agency that runs Ann Arbor's bus system has revised its ad policy but still won't accept an anti-Israel ad.

A federal judge last fall said the Ann Arbor Transportation Authority's policy against certain ads was vague and unconstitutional. The policy has been changed, but the agency still won't post an ad on buses that criticizes Israel.

The ad by Blaine Coleman would have skulls and bones and say, "Boycott 'Israel.' Boycott Apartheid." The bus agency says putting Israel in quotation marks implies that it doesn't exist. The agency says the ad also ridicules a group of people.

Judge Mark Goldsmith wants to read more legal filings from both sides before taking the next step. The lawsuit was filed by the American Civil Liberties Union.

-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013, 04:04 EST

GRAND RAPIDS NEWS
At: http://www.wwmt.com/template/inews_wire/wires.regional.mi/3ae8437c-www.wwmt.com.shtml

-----------------------------------------------


Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013
WOOD-TV NEWS (Grand Rapids, Michigan)

At: http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/michigan/ap_michigan/Ann-Arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-antiIsrael-ad_13895852


-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013, 4:04 AM

ABC 12 TV (Flint, Michigan)
At: http://www.abc12.com/story/20560551/ann-arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-anti-israel-ad


-----------------------------------------------


Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013

MLIVE.com, at http://www.mlive.com/newsflash/index.ssf/story/ann-arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on/76bb83e03748402e847472ea0421acda

-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013
In WLNS TV NEWS (Lansing, Michigan)


At: http://www.wlns.com/story/20560551/ann-arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-anti-israel-ad


-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013
Toledo News Now (WTOL and WUPW TV), Toledo, Ohio

At: http://www.toledonewsnow.com/story/20560551/ann-arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-anti-israel-ad


-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013
WWTV/WWUP-TV 9&10 News (Cadillac, Michigan)
Affiliated with CBS

At: http://www.9and10news.com/story/20560551/ann-arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-anti-israel-ad


-----------------------------------------------
Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013

Your Hometown Stations (Lima, Ohio)


At: http://www.hometownstations.com/story/20560551/ann-arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-anti-israel-ad

-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013
WANE TV (Fort Wayne, Indiana)


At: http://www.wane.com/dpp/news/michigan/ap_michigan/Ann-Arbor-bus-agency-wont-budge-on-antiIsrael-ad_96897472

-----------------------------------------------

Ann Arbor bus agency won't budge on anti-Israel ad
January 11, 2013
WLAJ TV News (Lansing, Michigan)


At: http://www.wlaj.com/template/inews_wire/wires.regional.mi/3ae8437c-www.wlaj.com.shtml


******************************** 

In the Michigan Daily: "U.S. government should halt sanctions on Iran"

"U.S. government should halt sanctions on Iran"

BY MOZHGAN SAVABIEASFAHANI AND AZADEH SHAHSHAHANI
January 11, 2013

Michigan Daily (University of Michigan student newspaper)
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Letter to the Editor

At: http://michigandaily.com/opinion/01letter-editor-halt-sactions-iran11


Sanctions on Iraq may have killed as many as 576,000 children, according to a 1995 report by two scientists who surveyed the country for the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization. They also found sharply rising malnutrition among the young, suggesting that more children will be at risk in the coming years.

Today, with an epidemic of birth defects appearing in many Iraqi cities, the country is still grappling with the aftermath of war-related and sanctions-related public health issues.

Iran is a country of 80 million people. Over 19 million Iranians are under 14 years of age and most vulnerable to the effects of sanctions.

Have we learned anything from the death of half a million Iraqi children? If we have, then the University of Michigan should raise its voice, as it has for other issues, to demand that the U.S. government halt all sanctions on Iran.


*******************************************

“Anti-Israel advertisement dispute continues..."

“Anti-Israel advertisement dispute continues with new AATA policy”

By Stephanie Shenouda, Daily Staff Reporter

Published January 9, 2013

MICHIGAN DAILY (At the University of Michigan; Ann Arbor)

 

At: http://michigandaily.com/news/aata-continues-fight-right-censor-controversial-advertisement

No resolution was reached yesterday during a conference between the Ann Arbor Transit Authority and Ann Arbor resident Blaine Coleman in an endless battle over AATA’s decision not to post Coleman’s advertisement featuring anti-Israeli sentiments on their buses.

The two-year-old case continues as both parties were asked to submit supplemental briefs before U.S. District Judge Mark Goldsmith makes his decision, possibly in the next few weeks.

 

In January of 2011, Coleman purchased advertisement space on the side of an Ann Arbor bus. The ad had many images of skulls accompanied by the words “Boycott Israel”. The AATA rejected the advertisement, asserting that the advertisement violated two provisions of its policy: that the advertisement be in “good taste” and that it “not contain any scorn or ridicule”.

 

However, in September 2012 Goldsmith ruled that AATA’s advertising policy was unconstitutional. Coleman, however, sought further relief, arguing that his first amendment right to free speech guaranteed him the right to purchase the advertisement.

After revising its policy and revisiting the advertisement earlier this month, the AATA upheld its decision not to run it. Again, noting it ridiculed an individual or group and was in violation of their advertising standards.

 

“We felt like the ad was demeaning and offensive of a certain group and was outside our standards as the AATA,” AATA Chairman Charles Griffith said in an interview. “We reserve the right to reject advertisements that are outside our standards and stand by our decision.”

 

Griffith clarified that the reasons for banning the advertisement are still “valid” within the AATA’s new policy and does not expect the AATA to change their views on this matter....

 

*******************************************
 

The University of Toronto’s Graduate Student Union (GSU) votes overwhelmingly to support boycott and divestment against Israel--

"GSU endorses boycott of investment in Israel"

By Rwayda Al-kamisi
Published: 7 January 2013
THE VARSITY (University of Toronto), Vol CXXXIII, No. 12, at:

 http://thevarsity.ca/2013/01/07/gsu-endorses-boycott-of-investment-in-israel/



The University of Toronto’s Graduate Student Union (GSU) voted overwhelmingly in favor of a resolution to endorse the campaign known as “Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions” (BDS) against the state of Israel at their meeting on December 10.

BDS calls for U of T to refrain from investments in companies, including Lockheed Martin and Hewlett Packard, that are described as profiting from “illegal occupation of Palestinian land” and the “collective punishment of Palestinians.”

One hundred and fifty graduate students were present at the meeting, of which 97 per cent voted in favor of the motion. Some students who opposed the motion said they felt that the GSU violated their bylaws by not advertising the motion prior to the meeting.

Erin Oldynski, external commissioner for the GSU, promised that “a motion such as this is only the beginning of a much longer campaign.” Other Canadian universities have passed similar resolutions, including York University, University of Regina, and Carleton University.



***************************************************

Boycott "Israel" advertisement rejected again by Ann Arbor Transportation Authority:

Ann Arbor Chronicle:
AATA rejects anti-Israel ad on buses for second time

ANN ARBOR.com
January 4, 2013

At: http://www.annarbor.com/news/aata-rejects-anti-israel-ad-on-buses-for-second-time/

The Ann Arbor Transportation Authority has, for the second time, rejected a request from Ann Arbor resident Blaine Coleman to place an anti-Israel advertisement on its buses, the Ann Arbor Chronicle reported.

 

The board met Thursday to consider the request. AATA was under a court order to reconsider the ad, which it first rejected more than a year ago. AATA considered the ad Thursday under a revised advertising policy.

The rejected proposed advertisement.

AATA’s original rejection of the ad prompted a lawsuit on Coleman’s behalf from the American Civil Liberties Union, which alleged AATA violated Coleman’s First Amendment right to free speech and 14th Amendment right to due process.

In rejecting the ad in November of 2011, AATA said the ad violated AATA’s policy prohibiting any advertisement that “defames or is likely to hold up to scorn or ridicule a person or group of persons.”

The ad features the words “Boycott ‘Israel,’ Boycott Apartheid,” with the word Israel in quotation marks. It includes a cartoonish black-and-white image that depicts a skeleton-like figure holding a skull in its right hand and a bone in its left….

...Read the article in the Ann Arbor Chronicle.

 

*********************************************